Welcome to Stuff-A-Bagel
At Stuff-A-Bagel, located in West Islip, NY, bagel enthusiasts are treated to a delightful array of fresh, handcrafted bagels and delicious sandwiches. Under new ownership, this inviting establishment focuses on quality, with everything made in-house, from bagels to coffee cakes. Patrons rave about the diverse menu, which features not only bagels but also mouth-watering lunch sandwiches and salads. The clean and welcoming atmosphere enhances the experience, making it an ideal spot for a quick bite or a leisurely meal. Whether you're craving classic sandwiches like pastrami or unique bagel offerings, Stuff-A-Bagel delivers in taste and satisfaction.
-
425 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795 Hotline: (631) 661-7646
Welcome to Stuff-A-Bagel, a hidden gem located at 425 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795. This delightful bagel shop is redefining breakfast and lunch, bringing a fresh wave of flavors to the community. With a phone number of (631) 661-7646, it's never been easier to satisfy your bagel cravings.
Under new ownership, Stuff-A-Bagel has undergone an impressive transformation, evident in both their inviting atmosphere and the quality of their offerings. As customer reviews highlight, the bagels here are nothing short of excellent, featuring a vast selection that caters to every palate. From classic favorites to innovative creations, the choices are plentiful.
- Grilled Cheese Sandwich - $6.95
- Roast Beef Sandwich - $16.95
- Honey Maple Turkey Sandwich - $9.50
- Chicken Cutlet Sandwich - $14.95
Additionally, Stuff-A-Bagel offers an array of lunch salads, perfect for those seeking a lighter option, like their Tuna Salad served on a bagel or roll for $16.95.
What truly resonates is the commitment to quality; everything is made in-store. From the bagels to the delicious coffee cakes and muffins, each item is crafted with care. One delighted patron, Jesse B., updated their experience, praising the cleanliness of the store and specifically mentioning the excellent egg sandwiches. It's the small, thoughtful touches that make dining here an experience rather than just a meal.
In summary, Stuff-A-Bagel stands as a testament to good food and community spirit. Whether you're stopping in for a quick bite or enjoying a leisurely meal, the flavors and warm atmosphere will keep you coming back for more. Why not give them a try? Your next favorite bagel is waiting!
The bagels are excellent. There are a lot of bagel choices. You could also get snacks and hot or cold drinks.
Updating my one star review from 4yrs ago. Stuff A Bagel is under new ownership/management. Everything is made in-store, bagels, coffee cakes, and muffins. Store is nice and clean and the new owner makes an excellent egg sandwich. So glad I can stop at the closest bagel store again instead of driving into Babylon.