Stuff-A-Bagel Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Stuff-A-Bagel, where passion for bagels meets culinary innovation. Nestled in the heart of West Islip, NY, this cozy eatery beckons bagel enthusiasts with an impressive array of freshly made bagels, sandwiches, and salads. With an emphasis on quality, every item on the menu is crafted in-house, ensuring a delightful experience from the first bite to the last crumb.
Dive into their extensive selection of lunch salads, featuring classics like egg, tuna, and chicken salad served on your choice of a bagel or roll, all starting around $15.95. For sandwich lovers, options range from the comforting grilled cheese at just $6.95 to the hearty roast beef sandwich for $16.95.
The community has welcomed the new ownership wholeheartedly, as evident from glowing reviews about the clean ambiance and fantastic egg sandwiches. Experience the warmth of Stuff-A-Bagel, where every visit promises delicious food and a welcoming atmosphere.
Lunch Salads
Chicken Salad
on a bagel or roll
Tuna Salad
on a bagel or roll
Egg Salad
Ham and Swiss Melt Sandwich
Served with butter and garlic.
Roast Beef Sandwich
Pastrami Sandwich
Bologna and American Sandwich
Chicken cutlet Sandwich
Cracked Peppermill Turkey Sandwich
Turkey Sandwich
Honey Maple Turkey Sandwich
Liverworst Sandwich
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Salami and Cheese Sandwich
Lunch Sandwiches
Lunch Combos
Tuna Plate
Tuna, lettuce, and tomato on a platter. Comes with pickle and your choice of bagel.
Whitefish Salad Platter
Whitefish, lettuce, and tomato on a platter. Comes with a pickle and your choice of bagel.
Turkey Club Wrap
Chicken cutlet Wrap
chicken cutlet, cheese, lettuce, tomato.
Lunch Wraps
Lunch Beverages
Snapple Ice Tea
16 oz.
Poland Spring Water Bottle
12 oz.
20oz Bottle Soda
Iced Coffee
Homemade Sweet Iced tea
Hungry Man
Three eggs, ham, bacon, sausage, and double cheese on a bagel or roll.
Western Omelette
Scrambled eggs with ham, green, and red peppers, onions.
Ham and Cheese Omelette
Scrambled eggs, with ham and cheese omelette on your choice of bagel, roll, bread or plate.
Potato and Egg Sandwich
Home fried potatoes and 2 eggs on your choice of bagel, roll, bread, or plate.
Cheese Omelette
Scrambled eggs and cheese omelet on your choice of bagel, roll, bread, or plate.
Bacon and Egg Sandwich
Two eggs, bacon on your choice of bagel, roll, bread, or plate.
Sausage and Egg Sandwich
Two eggs, sausage patty on your choice of bagel, roll, bread or plate
Egg Whites and Turkey Sandwich
Two egg whites, turkey on your choice of bagel, roll, bread or plate.
Ham and Egg Sandwich
Two eggs, and ham on your choice of bagel, roll, bread, or plate.
Jumbo Egg Sandwich
Two eggs on your choice of bagel, roll, bread, or plate.
Breakfast Sandwiches
Breakfast on a Bagel
Nova Lox and Cream Cheese
Lox Cream Cheese
Mixed Cream Cheese
Olive, strawberry, bacon and cheddar, vegetable, scallion cinnamon raisin, walnut, chocolate chip, vegetable, and scallion.
Plain Cream Cheese
Cream Cheese and Jelly
Buttered Bagel
Buttered Roll
Coffee
Tea
Tropicana Orange Juice
16 oz.
Nesquik Milk
14 oz. Your choice of chocolate, strawberry.
Homemade Iced tea
Breakfast Beverages
1/2 Dozen Bagels
1/2 Dozen Bagels
Describe in order notes the number of selected bagels.
1 Dozen Bagels
Describe in order notes the number of selected bagels.